Fighting Fire with Fire II: Countering Film Propaganda with Video Podcasting
Main Article Content
Abstract
In a prior article for this journal (Jason 2023), I explored the effectiveness of using film to counter propaganda in film. In this piece, I want to explore the use of video podcasts to counter propaganda in film. I begin by summarizing the theory of propaganda I am introduced earlier, by which propaganda can be reasonable or deceptive on six different scales. I then summarize the 2022 Netflix documentary series Meltdown, about the accident at the nuclear power plant at Three Mile Island (in Central Pennsylvania). This accident was (and is to this day) the biggest nuclear power failure in American history. I discuss how the series was reviewed in the print media. I then turn to two videos that rebutted Meltdown, and show how their explicit and implicit criticisms of the Netflix series fit our criteria for assessing the rationality of propaganda. The first video was made by Jesse Freeston, and had limited viewership. The other was made by science communicator and widely followed podcaster Kyle Hill. I show how each effectively exposed deceptive messages propagated by Netflix series. I finish the article by suggesting that video podcasts have advantages in rebutting film propaganda that making counter propaganda films lack: video podcasts can be made much more quickly and much less expensively. But when it comes to informing the public about the costs and benefits of a technology as complex as nuclear power, films and videos are of limited use. Unfortunately, this is how citizens typically get their information.
Article Details
References
Barrett, Lake (2022). What Really Happened at Three Mile Island?. ANS.org webinar. https://www.ans.org/webinars/view-tmi2022/
Camacho, Melissa. (2022). TV Review of Meltdown: Three Mile Island. Common Sense Media. https://www.commonsensemedia.org/tv-reviews/meltdown-three-mile-island
D’Addario, Daniel. (2022). Meltdown: Three Mile Island is a Methodical Look at an American Disaster. https://variety.com/2022/tv/reviews/meltdown-three-mile-island-netflix-1235256986/.
Decouple Media.org. (2023). About the Team. https://www.decouplemedia.org/about.
EIA (U. S. Energy Information Administration). (2023). What is U.S. Electricity by Energy Source?. Link: https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=427&t=3.
Fabian, John. (2022). Meltdown: Drama Disguised as a Documentary” in. Nuclear News. https://www.ans.org/news/article-4016/meltdown-drama-disguised-as-adocumentary/
Freeston, Jess. (2022). Fact-Checking Netflix’s Meltdown: Three Mile Island, Decouple Media podcast. https://www.ans.org/news/article-4016/meltdown-drama-disguised-as-a documentary/
Gigerenzer, Gerd. (2004). Dread Risk, September 11, and Fatal Traffic Accidents,” Psychological Science, Vol. 15, No. 4, pp. 286-287.
Herrick, James. (2019). Argumentation: Understanding and Shaping Arguments (7th ed.), State College, PA: Strata Publishing, Inc.
Hill, Kyle. (2022). Three Mile Island What Really Happened, YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cL9PsCLJpAA.
------------. (2022). Twitter feed. https://twitter.com/Sci_Phile/status/1531379846672023552?lang=en.
History.com Editors. (2009). Karen Silkwood Dies in Mysterious One Car Crash. History.com. https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/karen-silkwood-dies-in-mysterious-one-car crash.
Horton, Adrian. (2022). Dodged a Bullet’: How Whistleblowing Averted a Second US Nuclear Disaster. https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2022/may/05/meltdown-three-mile-island-netflix-us-nuclear-accident.
Jason, Gary J. (2023). Fighting Fire with Fire I: Using Film to Counter Film Propaganda. Propaganda: Journal of Communication Studies, Vol. 3, No. 1: 49-67. https://journal.neolectura.com/index.php/propaganda/article/view/1132/961.
Jason, Gary J. (2022). The Critical Thinking Book. Ontario, Canada: Broadview Press.
Kats, Rimma. (2022). Netflix Statistics: How many Subscribers does Netflix Have?. Insider Intelligence. https://www.insiderintelligence.com/insights/netflix-subscribers/.
Keller, Joel. (2022). Meltdown: Three Mile Island,” Decider.com. https://decider.com/2022/05/04/meltdown-three-mile-island-netflix-review/.
Meltdown: Three Mile Island Director: Kief Davidson; Production studios: Moxie Pictures & MAS; executive directors: Carla Santos and Michael Shamberg; 4 episodes, 2 hours, 52 minutes (2022). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAOIH8HRdDo.
Mitchell, Alex. (2022). The Nuclear Nightmare that Almost Took out the East Coast. New York Post. https://nypost.com/2022/05/04/how-a-brave-engineer-saved-the-us-from-nuclear-catastrophe-new-doc/.
Mitchell, Molli. (2022). Do People Still Work at and Live Near Three Mile Island? Newsweek.com. https://www.newsweek.com/do-people-still-work-three-mile-island-live-middletown-pennsylvania-netflix-1704265.
Molotsky, Irvin. (1986). Rickover’s Son Says His Father was Exploited,” The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/1986/07/11/us/rickover-s-son-says-his-father-was-exploited.html.
Moore, James ( 2022). Netflix’s Three Mile Island documentary highlights the real issue with nuclear power: people,” in The Independent. https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/three-mile-island-netflix-documentary-nuclear-power-b2078962.html.
Norton, Romey. (2022). Review: Meltdown: Three Island Netflix Series,” Ready Steady Cut. https://readysteadycut.com/2022/05/02/review-meltdown-three-mile-island-netflix-series/.
Owen, Rob. (2022). V Talk: Meltdown Revisits Three Mile Island,” Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. https://triblive.com/aande/movies-tv/tv-talk-meltdown-revisits-three-mile-island-star-trek-strange-new-worlds-premieres/.
Pawar, Pramod. (2022). Podcast Statistics 2022 Future, Demographics and Advertising Trends, EnterpriseAppsToday. https://www.enterpriseappstoday.com/stats/podcast-statistics.html.
Perron, Charles. (1984). Normal Accidents: Living With High Risk Technology Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Todd, Andrew. (2019). How The China Syndrome Brought Down the Nuclear Power Industry. in BirthMoviesDeath.com. https://birthmoviesdeath.com/2019/06/28/how-the-china-syndrome-brought-down-the-nuclear-power-industry.
Weart, Spencer R. (2012). The Rise of Nuclear Fear, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Wikipedia. Three Mile Island Accident, en.wikipedia.org. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident.
World Nuclear Association. (2023). Nuclear Power Reactors. https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/nuclear-power-reactors/nuclear-power-reactors.aspx.